Assisted Suicide: An Unhindered Choice


Judith A. Lewis of Huntington Beach wrote a convincing refutation of Joseph Perkins’ view that no one should have the right to take their own life. I wonder if Joseph Perkins has had to sit helplessly by while a loved one withered away afflicted by Alzheimer’s ? I doubt it. The Orange County Register columnist should be more responsible and circumspect about espousing unconditional dogma.

The real divide on this gripping issue of assisted suicide hinges on whose life it is anyway. Many religious types believe your life is a gift from God. Therefore suicide becomes murder in the eyes of God. However, a very significant percentage of people around the globe do NOT believe their life is a gift from any form of transcendence. These folks naturally believe that one has a right to choose whether their life ends painfully while burdening their family with exorbitant medical bills. 

Thank you Judith for speaking out against theocratic tripe that insists on dictating how people should handle a very private matter!

Register columnist Joseph Perkins believes no one should have the right to assisted suicide [“Soft on assisted suicide,” Columns, Jan. 25]. He criticizes prosecutors for their lack of harsh punitive action for compassionate acts of assisted suicide. From his column, it seems he would support punishing, to the full extent of the law, those who act out of love and loyalty to respect someone’s end-of-life wishes.

I, as a senior citizen, support legalizing assisted suicide in cases where death is imminent from a terminal illness. In addition, I and many seniors believe advance directives should legally authorize compassionate euthanasia when we no longer have our faculties or have lost the ability to care for ourselves.

We oppose a theocratic government that denies us that choice because of the religious beliefs of others(Thank you Judith for standing strong against religious zealotry). The notion of “sanctity of life” comes out of religious beliefs that God decides when one should die. Most people with those religious beliefs have no problem, however, with medical interventions to prolong life.

We seniors witness Alzheimer’s and dementia patients living nearly comatose for years in nursing homes or needing the full-time care of family.


4 comments on “Assisted Suicide: An Unhindered ChoiceAdd yours →

  1. I know you are not talking about the suicide of the wife of Hal Bacharach who jumped out of the 8th floor of Sutton Apartments, Harlem NYC where she landed flat on her back shielding her baby who bounced off her according to Newton’s laws and survived. I

    She had been arguing with her husband and suffering from postpartum depression. Couples argue all the time, so her husband is not to blame.

    1. Scheving, Larissa Michelle
      17 October 1991 – 07 December 2011

      Our Remembrance
      Do not stand at my grave and weep, I am not there; I do not sleep. I am a thousand winds that blow, I am the diamond glints on snow, I am the sun on ripened grain, I am the gentle autumn rain. When you awaken in the morning’s hush, I am the swift uplifting rush of quiet birds in circling flight. I am the soft starlight at night. Do not stand at my grave and cry, I am not there; I did not die.

      This touching note is tough when interpreted too literally. Somebody who kills themselve did choose to die

      The words of Nate Pyle are honestly refreshing for those coping with unbearable torment and pain. “God won’t give you more than you can handle”

      Unfortunately the over three thousand faces of suicide did not feel that way.

  2. Lynn Poppe of Omaha Nebraska, who tried to kill herself, got out of her boyfriend’s truck and began walking across a highway where the average speed was around 65 MPH.

    Police said it appeared she was leisurely walking into traffic, attempting to get hit by a vehicle. Her calmness was explained by the tranquility one feels when makeing a difficult decision.

  3. Did Eastern NM Medical Center in Roswell release senior Jose Saenz without a designated person to pick him up?
    Sargent hector Ramirez ingeniously triangulated the location of the partially senile gentleman to a hayfield near east 19th and north red bridges road when Jose mistakenly told them he was was south on Hobson!

    Much thanks to caring neighbor Selena Ureta for helping saving the old gentleman on a night where exposure to cold could have been life threatening.

Leave a Reply